Why should it be legal to bet online on a horse race in another state, but not legal to bet on a basketball game in one’s own state? If Native American tribes can establish new, legal, physical places where adults can gamble, why shouldn’t someone be able to do the same in cyberspace?
Similarly, the Las Vegas-based public company American Wagering, owner of Leroy’s Horse and Sports Place in Nevada, also operates a sports gambling site located in Canberra called MegaSports (www.megasports.com.au). A Ninemsn spokesperson says that the site does not now offer online gambling and would not comment on future plans. The Justice Department doesn’t think that online casinos (including those that offer gambling on sports events) can legally conduct business in the United States, even if they are based in places where gambling is legal. Today, a roster on one “gambling portal” site lists well over 200. citizens, it will be increasingly tempting for them to turn to locations abroad. One Australian state, Queensland, is already awarding licenses for online gambling, and others may follow soon. But according to Inland CEO Don Speer, elusive profits need not be one of them. In the ’70s, Atlantic City legalized casino gambling; in the ensuing decades, state lotteries, Indian casinos, gaming ships, offtrack betting parlors and card clubs have sprouted across the landscape. Says Sinclair of Christiansen/Cummings: “You are going to feel more comfortable wagering with a Hilton than you will with Joe’s Casino.”
More than a year later, however, no cases have come to trial, and nine defendants have accepted plea bargains for state misdemeanor charges with no jail time. In most cases, this means operating out of Australia. Her higher-ups in the Justice Department appear to agree. Estimates range from $650 million to $1 billion a year, worldwide – a tiny fraction of the amount spent on more traditional formats. Even the precise number of online casinos is hard to calculate.
One major barrier to profitability is the law.
Today, Americans spend some $600 billion a year on legal gambling, making it by far the favored national pastime. Anyone over the age of 18 can set up an account with Centrebet and place money on a variety of worldwide sporting events, including U.S. “Ultimately, Internet gambling operators are selling a product. The American Gaming Association, a trade group of gaming firms, maintains this view regarding online wagering: “The industry has been state-regulated and we think it should remain that way. But following a 1997 indictment, the state of Missouri settled a suit against the company and its president, Michael Simone, for about $35,000. (The company’s Indian casino and Web-development divisions make more.) “This is the really exciting point, because I know where it goes from here,” Speer said in an interview. Packer is a man with a voracious gambling appetite. Legislators have considered enlisting Internet service providers to patrol for undesirable sites, although Internet gambling insiders consider that proposal dead on arrival. has had little cooperation from any other nation. One of Microsoft (MSFT)’s less-publicized adventures is Ninemsn, an Australia-based Internet service to which Bill Gates has pledged tens of millions of dollars. That makes for an Internet gambling environment too porous for U.S law enforcement to plug.
The office of U.S. “Federal legislation will make it difficult but not impossible for Internet gamblers in the U.S. I’ve not had problems being paid.”
Finally, the DoJ believes that any federal law must recognize that the Internet is different from other communications media: It’s a multifaceted communications medium that allows for both point-to-point transmission between two parties (like the telephone), as well as the widespread dissemination of information to a vast audience (like a newspaper).
Running an online casino carries all the usual challenges of Internet businesses, from low click-through rates to servers that fail.
Although it uses a CryptoLogic template similar to several other online casinos, Kennyrogerscasino.com may be unique in letting bettors wager as little as a penny at a time.
Prosecutors focus on sports betting
Intriguingly, though, all the bets that make up the U.S. Failure to account for that specificity in legislation could stifle the Internet’s growth or chill its use as a communications tool. The defendants, many of whom live abroad, were threatened with up to five years in prison and $250,000 fines. The minimum amount to begin an account varies. In 1998, the Senate passed, by a large margin, an amendment prohibiting Internet gambling, but that bill died before becoming law.
The prosecutors’ focus on sports bets appears to stem from legal precedent in the law they relied on. About 2,000 years later, Bugsy Siegel took the concept a step further and built the Flamingo Hotel in the desert town of Las Vegas. .
First, legislation should treat physical activity and cyberactivity in the same way. In January, MegaSports began taking Internet bets from Australians; it expects soon to allow global gambling on sporting events.
All the sites indicted by the U.S. Nor would it prohibit online fantasy sports leagues, online lotteries in states where they are legal, or online betting on any live horse race where it would otherwise be lawful to wager. That figure exaggerates the size of the Internet gambling sector, since some companies operate more than one online betting parlor. Together, these sites have about 4,300 registered customers in 96 countries around the world. That may suggest that, as some legal observers have argued, the 1961 federal Wire Act is too old and too loosely written to prohibit online gambling. “Think about what would happen to Wal-Mart (WMT), General Motors or Microsoft if these companies had to continue to dodge federal roadblocks to access their customers,” says Sebastian Sinclair, senior associate at Christiansen/Cummings Associates, a management consulting firm. White’s hesitancy suggests that the law may not be as solid as she thought when she indicted. (The company did not respond to repeated requests for an interview.)
Group calls for regulation of Net gambling
For years, another barrier to the growth of Internet gambling has been strong opposition from those most threatened by gambling sites: legal American casinos.
Nonetheless, some experts think the case could be made to stick. And for sports bettors – who make up a majority of online gamblers, according to industry insiders – the ease of using cyberbookies can’t be beat. … As Timothy L. Says Opel, “Bringing in the big names and established companies only adds credibility and visibility to what we’re already doing.”
Is it legal?
A few hurdles have to be cleared before such ventures can take off – beginning with the federal government. They almost always include slots, blackjack and video poker, but many sites carry more exotic games, from baccarat to pai gow. Justice believes that any legislation addressing criminal misuse of computers or computer systems (including the Internet) should have three vital characteristics. In a highly publicized March 1998 “raid,” Mary Jo White, the U.S. attorney for the Southern District of New York, indicted 14 managers of six Internet companies for offering gambling on their sites.
But a hard-core base will continue to turn to Internet betting for its clear advantages. attorney’s office theoretically operate out of the Caribbean. Bets generally range from $1 to as much as $300. to gain access to offshore sites,” says Sebastian Sinclair of Christiansen/Cummings.
Gambling is as at least as old as Christianity (that is, if Ben Hur can be trusted).
The amount spent on Internet gambling is harder to calculate. O’Brien observes in Bad Bet, his comprehensive account of America’s gambling industry, “Judging by dollars spent, gambling is now more popular in America than baseball, the movies and Disneyland combined.”
If such gamblers are not satisfied by options available to U.S. If, on the other hand, an activity is in the physical world – betting on horses, or casino betting with Indian tribes – it becomes subject to federal criminal sanction when it occurs in cyberspace. Like the Communications Act passed in the 1930s, technology has now leapfrogged the law. “And it is possible that records could be subpoenaed of various banks where these companies maintain accounts.”
That partnership leads many observers to believe that an online casino – using Microsoft platforms, of course – is in the works.
The original version of Kyl’s bill failed most of these tests. “We get daily reports, and you’ll see these people who spend a couple of hours gambling, and the total amount they bet is like $1.81,” says Thomas Holmes, Inland’s head of technology.
But over the last several months, at least some traditional casinos have pursued the time-honored strategy of joining an Internet gambling trend that they can’t beat. “Since there are no controls at present regarding Internet wagering, I would urge investors to shun these firms at present,” he says. Would-be wagerers open an account with a credit card, although some sites also accept cash and cashier’s checks. Passed during the term of crime-fighter Attorney General Robert Kennedy, the law was intended to outlaw betting over telephone lines. “I use the service because it’s convenient and I have access to it when I want,” says one online gambler.
Take Interactive Gaming and Communications, another publicly traded company, located in Blue Bell, Pa. Blackjack players can very easily count cards, or even consult odds charts; the Kennyrogerscasino.com site actually has a printable chart showing the best strategy for every possible hand of blackjack.
Is Microsoft betting too?
The potential action is too compelling for even the largest tech tycoons to resist. college and professional sports. Attorney White has proceeded slowly and quietly. If an activity is prohibited in the physical world but not on the Internet, the Internet becomes a safe haven for that criminal activity. Aruba, for one, is refusing to extradite any indicted individuals to the U.S., and thus far the U.S. “I wager on football games and usually bet in the neighborhood of $1,000 every weekend. But as more and more traditional firms become involved, the consumer will look for the brand name. For one thing, gambling from one’s home allows for a variety of techniques that would get one tossed out of a regular casino. Casino games are available on a site or via downloadable software.
So how is it that these companies appear to operate legally, but a dozen Caribbean cowboys found themselves under felony indictment?
You might think that the prospect of competing against the likes of Microsoft would terrify a $20 million company like Inland. In 1997, published reports put the total number of operating online casinos at 15. The vast majority of customers will satisfy their demand for commercial gambling through less onerous and risky alternatives, such as lotteries, bingo, pari-mutuels and casinos.”
Internet Gambling Worldwide, Past and Future
It’s not because they operate in any fundamentally different way. Almost all online gambling sites work the same. In November 1998, for example, a division of Hilton Hotels acquired the company that runs Centrebet, a Web and telephone sports-wagering system based in Australia (www.centrebet.com.au). Inland, for example, operates two Web sites in addition to the one bearing Kenny Rogers’ likeness: Casinoaustralia.com and Goodluckclub.com. (However, an HBO sports program attempted to locate one of these ventures in Aruba, and ultimately found that the genuine server was in a residential neighborhood in Bethlehem, Pa.) And the Caribbean nations would like to keep their haven status. At one point, Interactive Gaming looked like it could be an industry leader. attorney’s case involved the casinos’ sportsbooks. Kyl introduced a revised version earlier this year, removing some of the more onerous and hard-to-enforce provisions. The Standard obtained a Department of Justice analysis of the bill S. For decades, Vegas was about the only legal option for gamblers. He claims Inland’s Internet gambling business went slightly into the black in March, on annualized revenues of about $1 million. 474, introduced into the Senate by Arizona’s John Kyl in 1997 as the Internet Gambling Prohibition Act. The Internet is presently unregulated and we support a federal law regulating Internet gambling.”
But even if Congress comes up with the best-crafted legislation in history, there are significant factors beyond its control. Their case is based on the 1961 Wire Act. But the travails associated with fending off lawsuits have essentially put the company out of business. Tony Cabot, an attorney specializing in gaming issues, says flatly, “When you see Kerry Packer get together with Microsoft, you have to believe there is a future for this type of wagering.”
Does the seeming invincibility of online gambling make it an enticing business? Jason Ader of Bear Stearns, urges caution. FBI agents placed bets on games – uniformly National Football League matches, although many other options are available – and followed up, whether they won or lost. “The telephone is being used to facilitate these wagers and I believe the government has a solid case,” explains Tony Cabot, a Las Vegas-based gaming lawyer and author of a book on Internet gaming. The Wire Act obviously has no mention of wagering over the Internet. His equal partner is Australian tycoon Kerry Packer of the Crown Casino in Victoria. But they say the more bettors, the better. Even the firms that have enjoyed some stock-price popularity – such as Youbet.com – have shaky fundamentals. According to an analysis by Sue Schieder of Rolling Good Times, the online gambling magazine, the new legislation would not punish the casual bettor. Legislation tied to a particular technology may quickly become obsolete and require further amendment. But the growing acceptance of online betting and the Internet’s inherent ability to shatter jurisdictions bring the inconsistencies of American gaming law to a boil.
Second, legislation should be technology-neutral